Great and cheap cut made famous by Brazilians

Top Sirloin roast was on sale this week at Safeway this week, for just $7/lb, and I ordered one with a couple of dishes in mind (Beef Stroganoff and Cambodian beef sticks). What I got was sirloin cap. This is, indeed, part of the top sirloin, a triangular cut with a thick layer of fat on top – which Safeway nicely trimmed (though I had to trim it away for my uses).
This cut is prized in Brazil as picanha and has become popular in the US in recent years, as other once cheap cuts that could be used for steaks have become too expensive for regular use. I have no doubt that the same will happen to sirloin cap.
I will try making an actual roast next time it goes on sale, but for the time being I can say that the cut worked well for grilling as thin strips – it was tender but with a nice grain/pull -, but it failed as cubes for the stroganoff. I’m not surprised as sirloin in general tends to acquire a dusty texture when cooked wet. It might work if I’d cut it into thin slices here as well.

Update: Sirloin roast went on sale again and I got one planning to grill it – but fall weather is upon us, and I had a cold, so I didn’t feel like going outside to grill.
I oven-roasted the picanha, and I can’t say it was too successful. I did overcook it a little. The flavor was OK, somewhere between a top sirloin steak (which I don’t like) and a NY strip steak (which I do like). I overcooked it, but the texture wasn’t dusty. The problem is that it was a bit tough.
I might try this again next summer and grill it, but I wouldn’t buy it to cook in the oven *unless* I had to make a roast and couldn’t afford a tri-tip.






Recent Comments